Sugarfire 64 Menu
101 items in 16 sections · $2.49 – $44.00 · Barbecue Restaurant in O'Fallon, IL
Sugarfire 64’s menu lists 101 dishes and drinks, grouped into Specials, Starters, Combo Plates, Cheddar Jalapeno Sausage, Brisket, and Pork and more. Prices range from $2.49 to $44.00, and a typical item costs about $7.00. Popular choices include Chili Vanilli, Fried Green Tomatoes, 2 Meat Combo Plate, Sausage Link Sandwich, and Brisket 1 LB (Meat Only).
Specials 2
- Chili Vanilli$14.99
Brisket Chili dog with cheddar cheese and Diced onion on a toasted hoagie topped with tots on the side
- Family Packs$44.00
Family Packs for 5-6 People. 2 pounds of meat, 2 quarts of sides, bag of buns, and your choice of BBQ sauce.
Starters 3
- Fried Green Tomatoes$7.99
- Pork Belly Hush Puppies$6.99
- Wings$12.99
Combo Plates 3
- 2 Meat Combo Plate$20.49
(2 sides + fountain soda) Any 2 smoked meats
- 3 Meat Combo Plate$25.49
(2 sides + fountain soda) Any 3 smoked meats
- Meat Daddy$31.99
(2 sides + fountain soda) 4 bone rib, jalapeno cheddar sausage link, & 4oz each brisket, pulled pork, turkey
Cheddar Jalapeno Sausage 2
- Sausage Link Sandwich$10.99
- Sausage Link$6.99
Brisket 5
- Brisket 1 LB (Meat Only)$27.98
Just looking for a light meal, or maybe even a side dish to be added to your breakfast lunch or dinner? We offer servings of brisket by its lonesome in portions of 4oz., 1/2lb., or 1lb.
- Brisket 8 Oz (Meat Only)$13.99
Just looking for a light meal, or maybe even a side dish to be added to your breakfast lunch or dinner? We offer servings of brisket by its lonesome in portions of 4oz., 1/2lb., or 1lb.
- Brisket 4 Oz (Meat Only)$7.00
Just looking for a light meal, or maybe even a side dish to be added to your breakfast lunch or dinner? We offer servings of brisket by its lonesome in portions of 4oz., 1/2lb., or 1lb.
- Brisket Sandwich$15.99
Tasty brisket on a freshly baked bun. This plate comes with one of your favorite sides. Top with one of our tasty barbecue sauces to round it out.
- Brisket Plate$17.99
Grab a helping of our famous smoked brisket and pair it with your two favorite sides and a crisp fountain soda. Top this with something from our range of sauces for a flavor-balanced meal.
Pork 5
- Pork 1 LB (Meat Only)$19.98
Just looking for a light meal, or maybe even a side dish to be added to your breakfast lunch or dinner? We offer servings of pork by its lonesome in portions of 4oz., 1/2lb., or 1lb.
- Pork 8 Oz (Meat Only)$9.99
Just looking for a light meal, or maybe even a side dish to be added to your breakfast lunch or dinner? We offer servings of pork by its lonesome in portions of 4oz., 1/2lb., or 1lb.
- Pork 4 Oz (Meat Only)$5.00
Just looking for a light meal, or maybe even a side dish to be added to your breakfast lunch or dinner? We offer servings of pork by its lonesome in portions of 4oz., 1/2lb., or 1lb.
- Pork Sandwich$13.99
Delicious pulled pork on a freshly baked bun. This plate comes with one of your favorite sides. Top with one of our tasty barbecue sauces to round it out.
- Pork Plate$15.99
Grab a 6oz. or 8oz. helping of our famous pulled pork and pair it with your two favorite sides and a crisp fountain soda. Top this with with something from our range of sauces for a flavor-balanced meal.
Ribs 6
- Full Rack Ribs Only$31.99
Full-rack (12-bone) of our famous house-smoked ribs
- 1/2 Rack Ribs Only$20.99
1/2-rack (6-bone) of our famous house-smoked ribs
- 4 Bone Ribs Only$13.99
1/3-rack (4-bone) of our famous house-smoked ribs
- Full Rack Rib Plate$33.99
Full-rack (12-bone) of our famous house-smoked ribs and pair it with your favorite side and a crisp fountain soda. Top this with with something from our range of sauces for a flavor-balanced meal.
- 1/2 Rack Rib Plate$23.99
1/2-rack (6-bone) of our famous house-smoked ribs and pair it with your favorite side and a crisp fountain soda. Top this with with something from our range of sauces for a flavor-balanced meal.
- 4 Bone Rib Plate$15.99
Looking for something lighter? Grab a 1/3-rack (4-bone) of our famous house-smoked ribs and pair it with your favorite side and a crisp fountain soda. Top this with with something from our range of sauces for a flavor-balanced meal.
Salmon 3
- Salmon Sandwich$15.99
We serve smoked salmon in a 5oz. portion on a freshly baked bun. This plate comes with one of your favorite sides. Top with one of our tasty barbecue sauces to round it out.
- Salmon Solo$11.99
Just looking for a light meal, or maybe even a side dish to be added to your breakfast lunch or dinner? We offer servings of salmon by its lonesome in 5oz portions. This one doesn't come with any sides.
- Smoked Salmon Plate$18.99
Grab a 5oz. helping of our famous smoked salmon and pair it with your two favorite sides and a crisp fountain soda. Top this with with something from our range of sauces for a flavor-balanced meal.
Turkey 5
- Turkey 1 LB (Meat Only)$18.99
Just looking for a light meal, or maybe even a side dish to be added to your breakfast lunch or dinner? We offer servings of turkey by its lonesome in portions of 4oz., 1/2lb., or 1lb
- Turkey 8 Oz (Meat Only)$9.99
Just looking for a light meal, or maybe even a side dish to be added to your breakfast lunch or dinner? We offer servings of turkey by its lonesome in portions of 4oz., 1/2lb., or 1lb
- Turkey 4 Oz (Meat Only)$6.49
Just looking for a light meal, or maybe even a side dish to be added to your breakfast lunch or dinner? We offer servings of turkey by its lonesome in portions of 4oz., 1/2lb., or 1lb
- Turkey Sandwich$12.99
House-smoked turkey on a freshly baked bun. This plate comes with one of your favorite sides. Top with one of our tasty barbecue sauces to round it out.
- Turkey Plate$15.99
Grab a 6oz. or 8oz. helping of our famous smoked turkey and pair it with your two favorite sides and a crisp fountain soda. Top this with with something from our range of sauces for a flavor-balanced meal.
Burgers 2
- Single Burger + 1 Side$11.99
This solo-pattied single is grass fed beef blended daily from our proprietary mix of chuck, brisket and boneless short rib, hand-patted and griddle seared, seasoned only in sea salt and fresh cracked pepper then served on a real butter toas
- Double Burger + 1 Side$13.99
This double-pattied burger is served with one side. Grass fed beef blended daily from our proprietary mix of chuck, brisket and boneless short rib, hand-patted and griddle seared, seasoned only in sea salt and fresh cracked pepper then serv
Specialty Sandwiches 5
- Brisket Cheesesteak + Side$17.99
This is cheesesteak our style. This Philly-inspired sandwich with an east-coast attitude is served with brisket with onions, peppers, and cheese on a hoagie roll.
- Brisket Dip + Side$17.99
Brisket, onions, swiss cheese, served on a hoagie roll.
- Carolina + Side$14.99
Choice of meat, cole slaw, mustard BBQ drizzle.
- Fried Green Tomato Sandwich$15.99
Cole slaw, cheddar cheese, ranch dressing, Carolina mustard sauce on toasted bread.
- Big Muddy + Side$16.99
Salads 2
- Chef Salad$15.99
This meat-full meal in a salad is brought to you by field greens and topped with brisket, turkey, a hard boiled farm egg, tomato, cucumber, cheddar cheese, red onion, lettuce, ranch dressing or cider vinaigrette.
- Smoked Turkey Caesar Salad$15.99
Our take on this traditional salad is served with romaine lettuce, creamy caesar dressing and topped with a heaping helping of our daily house-smoked turkey, a splash of freshly grated parmesan cheese and house-made croutons.
Sides (Single) 13
- *Baked Beans$4.25
- *Cole Slaw$4.25
- *French Fries$4.25
- *Potato Salad$4.25
- Side Salad$4.25
- Cornbread$4.25
- BBQ Chips$4.25
- Mac & Cheese$4.25
- Au Gratin Potatoes$4.25
- Spinach Souffle$4.25
- Collard Greens$4.25
- Glazed Carrots$4.25
- Broccoli Salad$4.25
Sides (Bulk) 16
- Baked Beans Gallon$39.49
This hot, spicy, side is prepared with love daily. Our tangy baked beans are the perfect side to your meat-ful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart (usually for 4-6 people) or by the gallon (usually for 15-20 people).
- Baked Beans Quart$13.49
This hot, spicy, side is prepared with love daily. Our tangy baked beans are the perfect side to your meat-ful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart (usually for 4-6 people) or by the gallon (usually for 15-20 people).
- Baked Beans Pint$7.49
This hot, spicy, side is prepared with love daily. Our tangy baked beans are the perfect side to your meat-ful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart (usually for 4-6 people) or by the gallon (usually for 15-20 people).
- Baked Beans 6oz$4.25
This hot, spicy, side is prepared with love daily. Our tangy baked beans are the perfect side to your meat-ful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart (usually for 4-6 people) or by the gallon (usually for 15-20 people).
- Cole Slaw Gallon$39.49
This cool cabbage treat is prepared with love daily. Our mayo-based coleslaw is the perfect side to your meat-ful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart (usually for 4-6 people) or by the gallon (usually for 15-20 people).
- Cole Slaw Quart$13.49
This cool cabbage treat is prepared with love daily. Our mayo-based coleslaw is the perfect side to your meat-ful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart (usually for 4-6 people) or by the gallon (usually for 15-20 people).
- Cole Slaw Pint$7.49
This cool cabbage treat is prepared with love daily. Our mayo-based coleslaw is the perfect side to your meat-ful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart (usually for 4-6 people) or by the gallon (usually for 15-20 people).
- Cole Slaw 6oz$4.25
This cool cabbage treat is prepared with love daily. Our mayo-based coleslaw is the perfect side to your meat-ful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart (usually for 4-6 people) or by the gallon (usually for 15-20 people).
- French Fries Gallon$39.49
This hot, hand-cut potato delight is prepared with love daily. Our french fries are the perfect side to your meat-ful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart (usually for 4-6 people) or by the gallon (usually for 15-20 people).
- French Fries Quart$13.49
This hot, hand-cut potato delight is prepared with love daily. Our french fries are the perfect side to your meat-ful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart (usually for 4-6 people) or by the gallon (usually for 15-20 people).
- French Fries Pint$7.49
This hot, hand-cut potato delight is prepared with love daily. Our french fries are the perfect side to your meat-ful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart (usually for 4-6 people) or by the gallon (usually for 15-20 people).
- French Fries 6oz$4.25
This hot, hand-cut potato delight is prepared with love daily. Our french fries are the perfect side to your meat-ful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart (usually for 4-6 people) or by the gallon (usually for 15-20 people).
- Potato Salad Gallon$39.49
This cool potato treat is prepared with love daily. Our mayo-based potato salad is the perfect side to your meat-ful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart (usually for 4-6 people) or by the gallon (usually for 15-20 people).
- Potato Salad Quart$13.49
This cool potato treat is prepared with love daily. Our mayo-based potato salad is the perfect side to your meat-ful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart (usually for 4-6 people) or by the gallon (usually for 15-20 people).
- Potato Salad Pint$7.49
This cool potato treat is prepared with love daily. Our mayo-based potato salad is the perfect side to your meat-ful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart (usually for 4-6 people) or by the gallon (usually for 15-20 people).
- Potato Salad 6oz$4.25
This cool potato treat is prepared with love daily. Our mayo-based potato salad is the perfect side to your meat-ful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart (usually for 4-6 people) or by the gallon (usually for 15-20 people).
Dessert 9
- Pecan Pie - Slice$4.99
- Key Lime Pie - Slice$4.99
- Sugarfire Pie - Slice$4.99
- 2 Churros$6.00
- 1 Churro$4.00
- Mississippi Mud Pie - Slice$4.99
- 1 Chocolate Chip Cookie$2.49
- 2 Chocolate Chip Cookies$3.59
- 3 Chocolate Chip Cookies$4.59
Beverages 20
- Bottle Black Cherry$3.99
- Bottle Diet Lucky Club Cola$3.99
- Peppermint Snow$3.99
- Bottle Frostie Root Beer$3.99
- Bottle Grape$3.99
- Bottle Lemonade$3.99
- Bottle Lucky Club Cola$3.99
- Bottle Orange$3.99
- Bottle Red Cream$3.99
- Bottle Ski$3.99
- Bottle Sparkling Life$3.99
- Fountain Black Cherry$3.25
- Fountain Diet Lucky Cola$3.25
- Fountain Lemonade$3.25
- Fountain Lucky Club Cola$3.25
- Fountain Orange$3.25
- Fountain Root Beer$3.25
- Fountain Ski$3.25
- Sweet Tea$3.25
- Unsweet Tea$3.25
Menu items and prices are provided for information and may have changed (last updated April 2026). Allergen information is not included – please ask the restaurant.